The term Emotional Intelligence (EI) is increasingly well known and often cited as the key to effective workplace relationships. It was first popularised in1995 by Daniel Goleman – originally a science journalist now a consultant/academic at Rutgers University Graduate School in New Jersey.
Goleman defines EI as:
It is, in other words, that critical group of non-cognitive skills, capabilities and competencies, which help someone control and manage their emotional response to events and pressures.
Research by Goleman and others suggests that EI is what really makes the difference between an effective manager, and the rest – which is why it’s so hugely beneficial to both organisations and individuals. This is not to say that intelligence (IQ) and technical skills are not important, but they are essentially threshold capabilities. That is, they are, in a sense, entry-level requirements for executive positions. Once in that position, it is EI which then makes the difference to how well an individual performs.
In a detailed study involving analysis of competency models in 188 companies, and a further extensive study of what constituted ‘star performers’ in these organisations, Goleman and his team drew the following conclusions:
This has been supported by many other studies, including one by the initially sceptical Higgs & Dulewicz at Henley Management Centre. In a study of 100 management and business leaders over a 7-year period, they found that ‘emotional intelligence was more highly related to success than IQ alone.’
Studies have also found that EI is important in many different roles, from fundraising to project management to service delivery. Any job that requires someone to work well with other people, to perform effectively in high-pressure situations and to deal calmly with emotive issues, needs that person to be emotionally intelligent. As well as understanding the mechanics of their job, they also need to understand both themselves and those they work with.
This need to work well with others and deal with pressure becomes more marked the more senior the person considered. Goleman believes, from his study of star performers, that in senior leadership positions nearly 90% of the difference in profile between a star and average performer can be attributed to emotional intelligence factors rather than cognitive abilities.
It is the new world of work which has accentuated the need for – and rise of – emotional intelligence. Greater competition, increased speed and quantity of information, working across sites, regions – and sometimes different countries – has meant that people have to cope with unprecedented levels of change, and increased levels of pressure at work.
People’s expectations of what they want from their organisations and leaders have altered. Staff now need to feel their manager is ‘worthy’ of their ‘followership’ rather than simply ‘following’ because of their role. Leaders and managers, in turn, have to be more flexible, more creative, more adept and more responsive if they want to survive let alone grow. And they need to be able to maintain their own motivation and momentum in difficult and challenging situations.
There are five key components which can be clustered into two areas of competence.
In the first, Personal Competence, there are three complementary elements: self-awareness, self-regulation and motivation.
The second, Social Competence, includes: empathy and social skills.
A framework devised by Goleman sets out these competencies in greater detail. Brief definitions and how you recognise the hallmarks of those possessing each component are given below.
|Dimension||Definition and metrics for success||Practical EI implication|
|Self-awareness||‘The ability to recognise and understand your emotions, and needs – and understanding their effect on others.’|
Indicators of high EI here are self-confidence, realistic self-assessment and a sense of humour. You are also more likely to set and achieve goals.
|Self-regulation||‘The ability to control ‘disruptive’ impulses and moods – and suspending judgement to think before acting.’|
Indicators are trustworthiness and integrity, comfort with ambiguity and openness to change. Mindfulness is also a useful tactic and metric.
|Motivation||‘A passion to pursue goals with energy and consistency – and to work for reasons that go beyond money or status.’|
Indicators are a strong drive to achieve and sustained optimism – even in the face of failure and lack of organisational commitment.
|Social Skill||‘Skills and proficiency in starting, managing and building on relationships with individuals and groups. The relationships need to be appropriate to the role.’|
Indicators are effectiveness in leading change, persuasiveness/influencing ability, experience in building and leading teams, and building rapport easily.
|Empathy||‘Recognising the emotional makeup of others – and skills in engaging with them appropriately and sensitively.’|
Indicators here are expertise in building and retaining relationships, sensitivity across diverse groups and cultures, and understanding the challenges others face.
If they take the right approach, research indicates that people can develop their emotional intelligence. And generally EI increases with age. There is an old fashioned word for this phenomenon – maturity. Yet even with maturity some people still need help to enhance their EI.
Scientifically, EI is born largely in the neurotransmitters of the brain’s limbic system, which governs feelings, impulses and drives. The limbic system learns best through motivation, extended practice and feedback. If you want to work on your EI you need to be committed to breaking old habits and establishing new ones through practice.
The checklist below offers some suggestions if you want to work in this area.
In the work situation there are specific additional points to think about. Again, practice and feedback are the key components to improvement.
It has been argued that emotional intelligence, is manipulative and underhanded. Examples are cited of people developing their EI and then using it to influence the behaviour of others in a way that’s unhelpful – or serves a personal purpose – rather than to achieve organisational goals.
To avoid this happening, it’s essential you’re clear on your values both as an individual and as an organisation. These values should be at the heart of the decisions you make in your role, including how you work with – and therefore influence – others. By being clear on your values, such Machiavellian tendencies can be held in check. Having a guiding sense of values and goals is essential to self-awareness, and reinforces the need for EI to be used for personal development and in the support of others.
Intelligence (IQ) and technical ability are important ingredients in effective management. But the total picture is not complete without EI. EI is the key ‘difference’ quality that turns a ‘normal’ performer into a ‘star’ performer. The components which combine to form EI, are essential for successful organisations.
If you’ve found this article helpful and you would like more information or to talk through how we might help your organisation, please call +44 (0)20 7978 1516 and speak to one of our experienced management consultants.
Alternatively, why not attend our Emotional Intelligence for Managers training programme? Learn to feel confident and in control of challenging situations, reduce stress and maintain motivation and momentum under pressure.
Need a quick answer to a specific challenge? Not sure what you're looking for or haven't time to search? Send me a message and we'll get back to you as soon as possible with an answer.
Or if you'd prefer to speak to someone, call 020 7978 1516.
Clare Segal, Director